Lionel Messi's hat-trick in Argentina's 3-0 win over Algeria at the 2026 FIFA World Cup has sparked debates about his fitness, form, and even his treatment by referees. At 38, the veteran forward scored his 16th World Cup goal, tying him with Miroslav Klose for the most goals in men's World Cup history. But the real question is: should he have been sent off for a challenge on Algeria captain Aissa Mandi?
Messi's performance was nothing short of spectacular. He was lean, mean, and urgent, showcasing his trademark decisiveness on the ball. His first goal was a masterpiece, a finish past Algeria goalkeeper Luca Zidane that only a late offside flag denied him. His second goal was a result of a gorgeous pass to Lautaro Martinez, and his third was a trademark finish whipped into the bottom corner from the edge of the box.
However, the challenge on Mandi is a cause for concern. The Polish referee Szymon Marciniak awarded only a free kick, but a yellow card or even a red card seemed warranted. Mandi was in control of the ball and there was little prospect of dispossessing him from Messi's position. To make a lunge like that, with his studs up, seemed incomprehensible, never mind dangerous.
This incident raises a deeper question: is Messi receiving special treatment from referees? While it's difficult to prove, it's not the first time opponents and fans have suggested as much. But even if he is, it's not surprising. Messi is a once-in-a-generation talent, and his presence on the pitch is a spectacle to behold.
Argentina's victory over Algeria was a significant step towards the knockout stage, and their coach Lionel Scaloni will be more than happy with his team's opening performance. However, there are questions about an over-reliance on Messi, but these will not trouble him any more than they did in Qatar in 2022.
Messi's hat-trick was a reminder of his brilliance and irrepressibility, and it's clear that he's still living in his world. But the challenge on Mandi is a reminder that even the greatest players are not above scrutiny, and that the lines between genius and recklessness can be thin.
